When Feedback Misses the Mark | Empowered Educator
A principal once shared a feedback conversation that didn't go the way she expected.
A teacher had been struggling with communication and missing deadlines. The principal prepared carefully, gathered examples, and shared her concerns.
The teacher listened quietly. But afterward, something changed.
The teacher became less engaged in meetings. Her communication even more limited.
The principal was confused,
"I gave the feedback. Why didn't it help?"
As we unpacked the conversation, it became clear that the principal had spent most of it explaining what was wrong. She spent very little time understanding what was happening.
The teacher later shared that she left feeling judged rather than supported.
That’s the human moment beneath the situation.
The goal of feedback isn't to prove a point; it's to increase awareness. When we feel attacked, we often protect ourselves. When we feel understood, we are more likely to reflect.
💫 Thought Spark 💫
The most effective feedback conversations create insight, not defensiveness.
Try This:
Creating safety during feedback conversations. Feedback works best when people feel safe enough to think, not just respond.
• Start with curiosity before conclusions.
• Be specific about what you observed rather than making assumptions about intent.
• Ask, "Can you help me understand what was happening from your perspective?"
Your Turn:
Think about the last piece of feedback you gave. Did the conversation create awareness? Or did it create protection? What might change if curiosity showed up before certainty?